Simone Carmen Johnson, a South African woman, is locked in a battle with the UK Home Office, fighting for her right to join her two lovers in the United Kingdom. This case, which has sent ripples through the legal and social spheres, highlights a clash between traditional notions of family and the evolving reality of diverse relationships in a globalised world.
Johnson, who identifies as polyamorous, has been in a committed relationship with two partners for several years. When her partners decided to move to the UK, she applied for an Unmarried Partner Visa on February 5th, hoping to join them. However, her application was rejected on June 26th, citing eligibility relationship requirements under UK immigration rules.
The refusal letter, which stated that the relationship did not meet the eligibility criteria, failed to adequately consider the legality and validity of polygamous marriages and relationships recognised in South Africa. This has raised concerns about discrimination and human rights violations.
“The refusal implies a lack of evidence for a genuine and subsisting relationship. This assessment neglects to consider the unique dynamics of polygamous relationships,” Johnson’s application for reconsideration reads.
The case has drawn support from human rights organisations and LGBTQ+ advocates, who argue that the decision reflects outdated views on family and relationships.
“We are urging the UK Home Office to reconsider this decision and recognise the validity of diverse family structures,” said Gwen Vermeulen, UK Immigration and British Nationality Senior Manager at Move Up UK Visa Solutions. “This refusal not only tears apart a loving family, but also raises troubling questions about the UK’s commitment to human rights and equality.”
Vermeulen further highlighted the legal precedent that supports the recognition of foreign marriages and relationships. “If unsuccessful, an appeal will be lodged with the relevant tribunal,” she added.
The case raises critical questions about the UK’s immigration policy and its ability to adapt to evolving global norms on family structures and LGBTQ+ rights. While polygamy is not legally recognised in the UK, it is legally recognised in South Africa, potentially violating Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which protects the right to family life.
This case throws a spotlight on the complexities of navigating international relationships in a world where traditional notions of family are being challenged. It also highlights the need for a more nuanced understanding of diverse family structures and the legal frameworks that govern them.
“This is not just about Simone’s individual case,” says sociologist Marry Mlilo. “It’s about the need for a broader conversation about how we define family and how we treat those who choose to live outside of traditional norms.”
The outcome of Johnson’s case will have significant implications for other polyamorous couples seeking to migrate to the UK. It could also set a precedent for how the UK deals with diverse family structures in the future.
